Proposition Types | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Code | Quantity | Quality | Exposition | Symbolic Notation | Example | Simple ConvErsIon Switch S, P | per AccidEns conversion Replace Quantity |
ContrApOsition (1) Switch S, P (2) Replace S, P with ~S, ~P | Obversion (1) Replace Quality (2) Replace P with ~P |
A | Universal | Affirmative | All S are P | ∀x S(x)→P(x) | All birds have wings | invalid | Some P are S | All non-P are non-S | No S are non-P |
E | Universal | Negative | No S are P | ∀x S(x)→ ¬P(x) | No birds have fins | No P are S | Some P are not S | Invalid | All S are non-P |
I | Particular | Affirmative | Some S are P | ∃x (S(x)∧P(x)) | Some birds swim | Some P are S | Does not exist | None | Some S are not non-P |
O | Particular | Negative | Some S are not P | ∃x (S(x)∧¬P(x)) | Some birds do not fly | invalid | Does not exist | Some non-P are not non-S | Some S are non-P |
Syllogistic Moods | ||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Major Premise | A | A | A | A | E | E | E | E | I | I | I | I | O | O | O | O |
Minor Premise | A | E | I | O | A | E | I | O | A | E | I | O | A | E | I | O |
Valid | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N * | Y | N * | Y | Y | N † | N † | Y | N * | N † | N *† |
* At least premise must be affirmative † At least one premise must be universal |
Syllogistic Figures | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Perfect | Imperfect | |||||||
Figure | 1st | 2nd | 3 d | 4th | ||||
Major Premise | M | P | P | M | M | P | P | M |
Minor Premise | S | M | S | M | M | S | M | S |
Conclusion | S | P | S | P | S | P | S | P |
Figure | 1st | 2nd | 3 d | 4th |
---|---|---|---|---|
Valid Syllogisms | AAA Barbara | AEE Camestres |
AAI Darapti | AAI Bramantip |
EAE Celarent | EAE Cesare |
IAI Disamis | AEE Camenes | |
AII Darii | EIO Festimo |
AII Datisi | IAI Dimaris | |
EIO Ferio | AOO Baroco |
EAO Felapton | EAO Fesapo | |
OAO Bocardo | EIO Fresison | |||
EIO Ferison |
Camestres |
---|
All P is M |
No S is M |
No S is P |
s - minor |
All P is M |
No M is S |
No S is P |
m |
No M is P' |
All S' is M |
No P' is S' |
s - conc |
Celarent |
No M is P' |
All S' is M |
No S' is P' |
Cesare |
---|
No P is M |
All S is M |
No S is P |
s - major |
Celarent |
No M is P |
All S is M |
No S is P |
Festimo |
---|
No P is M |
Some S is M |
Some S is not P |
s - major |
Ferio |
No M is P |
Some S is M |
Some S is not P |
Baroco |
---|
All P is M |
Some S is not M |
Some S is not P |
c - Contradict minor Set as conclusion |
Barbara |
All P is M |
All S is P |
All S is M |